Cistern Vs Septic Tank: How To Choose the Right System for Your Home

Did you know that choosing the wrong sewage system could cost you thousands in repair and maintenance down the road?

For homeowners, deciding between a cistern and a septic tank can be confusing, especially when both systems seem to serve similar functions.

This guide will demystify the differences between cisterns and septic tanks, helping you select the best system for your home.

By the end of this post, you'll understand the key differences, costs, and maintenance needs of each system, empowering you to make an informed decision.

---

Step #1: Understanding the Basics

Cistern vs Septic Tank: What’s the Difference?

At a glance, both cisterns and septic tanks are underground tanks designed to store liquids. However, their purposes and functions differ significantly:

• Cisterns are primarily used to store potable water, often collected from rainwater, for household use.
• Septic Tanks are designed to treat and dispose of wastewater from homes, storing it temporarily before it is filtered and released.

Key Differences

Here’s a quick comparison:

• Purpose:

  • Cisterns: Holds drinking water or rainwater.
  • Septic Tanks: Holds wastewater (both greywater and blackwater).

• Materials:

  • Cisterns: Made from concrete, fiberglass, steel, or plastic.
  • Septic Tanks: Typically made from concrete or fiberglass.

• Location:

  • Cisterns: Can be located above or below ground.
  • Septic Tanks: Always installed below ground.

• Safety Ratings:

  • Cisterns: Must meet FDA standards for potable water.
  • Septic Tanks: No such standards as they're for wastewater.

• Construction:

  • Cisterns: A single tank with an inlet and an outlet.
  • Septic Tanks: Divided into compartments with filtration for waste.

• Installation Cost:

  • Cisterns: Average cost around $7,000.
  • Septic Tanks: Average cost around $8,000.

• Maintenance:

  • Cisterns: Need to be emptied about once a month.
  • Septic Tanks: Pumped every 3–5 years.

Example

Consider a rural household that collects rainwater for drinking and household use. This home would benefit from a cistern for water storage. Conversely, a family in a suburban area with no access to municipal sewage services would require a septic tank for wastewater management.

Step #2: Pros and Cons

Cisterns

Pros:

• Can store potable water.
• Versatile installation (above or below ground).

Cons:

• Requires regular emptying.
• No filtration system, meaning water needs separate purification.

Septic Tanks

Pros:

• Efficient wastewater management and filtration.
• Less frequent maintenance compared to cisterns.

Cons:

• Strict installation requirements (must be below ground).
• Higher upfront installation costs.

Step #3: Installation and Maintenance

Installation

1. Cistern Installation:

   • Choose a location, either above or below ground.
   • Ensure proper plumbing connections for water inflow and outflow.
   • Cost: $6,500 to $8,000.

2. Septic Tank Installation:

   • Conduct a site evaluation to determine the best location.
   • Install the tank and leach field.
   • Cost: $3,500 to $12,000.

Maintenance

• Cisterns: Require monthly emptying to prevent overflow and contamination.
• Septic Tanks: Require pumping every 3–5 years. Regular inspections ensure the system functions efficiently.

Tips: Always hire professionals for installation and maintenance to avoid costly errors.

Step #4: Choosing the Right System for Your Home

Factors to Consider

• Water Usage: High water usage homes benefit more from septic systems due to their capacity and filtration.
• Purpose: If you need a system for drinking water storage, a cistern is suitable. For wastewater management, opt for a septic tank.
• Budget: Consider both the initial cost and long-term maintenance expenses.
• Location: Ensure your property can accommodate the chosen system, considering factors like space for a leach field for septic tanks.

Unique Insight: The Estimero 3-Step Cost Formula

Use this proprietary method to estimate your total cost:

1. Calculate Installation Cost: Factor in local labor rates and material costs.
2. Estimate Maintenance Costs: Consider frequency and local service rates.
3. Project Replacement Costs: Anticipate long-term expenses and system longevity.

Tips and Reminders

• Consult with Experts: Always consult with professionals to determine the best system for your specific needs.
• Regular Inspections: Schedule regular inspections to catch issues early.
• Consider Environmental Impact: Choose a system that minimizes environmental disruption.

Conclusion

Choosing the right sewage system is crucial for your home’s sustainability and functionality. Whether you opt for a cistern or septic tank, understanding the differences and maintenance needs will save you time and money.

Ready to stop guessing and start estimating like a pro? Try Estimero free today at Estimero.com — your smarter way to estimate any project.

---

FAQs

Q1: Can a cistern be used as a septic tank? No, cisterns are designed for water storage and not equipped for waste management like septic tanks.

Q2: How do I know when my septic tank needs pumping? Most systems need pumping every 3–5 years, but signs like slow drains or sewage odors indicate it's time.

Q3: What’s the lifespan of a septic tank? With proper maintenance, septic tanks can last 20–30 years.

Q4: Can cistern water be used for drinking? Yes, with proper filtration and purification, cistern water can be potable.

Q5: What are the signs of a failing sewage system? Overflow, slow drainage, and foul odors are key indicators.

For more insights and professional assistance, refer to our related articles and services at Estimero.