Construction Manager vs. General Contractor: Which Is Best for Your Project?

When embarking on a construction project, one of the critical decisions you must make is whether to hire a construction manager or a general contractor. Both roles are crucial, yet they serve different functions and can significantly impact the outcome of your project. In this guide, we dive deep into the differences between a construction manager and a general contractor, helping you understand who to hire for your specific needs.

The

Did you know that projects with professional oversight are 30% more likely to be completed on time and within budget?

If you're planning a home renovation or a new construction project, you might feel overwhelmed by the choices and the magnitude of the task. Coordinating architects, designers, and subcontractors can be a daunting endeavor, especially if you're unfamiliar with the construction industry.

Enter the construction manager and the general contractor—two roles that can make your project run smoothly. But which one is right for you? This article will help you decide.

Set Expectations

By the end of this post, you'll clearly understand the roles of construction managers vs. general contractors, their responsibilities, costs, and qualifications. You'll also learn how to choose the right professional for your project based on real-world examples and expert advice.

What are the Differences Between Construction Managers and General Contractors?

Construction managers are like the quarterbacks of the construction world. They step in during the pre-construction phase, steering the project from the planning stages to completion. A construction manager is your go-to person for budget management, scheduling, and coordination among various stakeholders.

General contractors, on the other hand, step in once the design phase is complete. They take charge of the construction phase, ensuring that the project is built according to the plans.

Key Responsibilities

• Construction Managers:

  • Oversee the project from start to finish.
  • Manage budgets and schedules.
  • Coordinate between the owner, architects, and subcontractors.

• General Contractors:

  • Supervise the construction site.
  • Manage subcontractors and ensure the work is done to code.
  • Handle procurement of materials.

Real-World Example

Consider a scenario where a homeowner wants to build a custom home. The homeowner hires a construction manager early in the process to coordinate with an architect for design and a general contractor who steps in later to manage the physical build. This seamless teamwork results in a home that meets the owner's vision and is completed on time.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Roles & Responsibilities

Step #1: Understand Their Roles

• Construction Manager's Role:

  • Envision them as the project’s backbone, ensuring everything aligns with the initial plan.
  • They are involved from day one, providing insights into budgeting, scheduling, and quality assurance.
  • They act as a liaison between you and various stakeholders, including architects and subcontractors.

• General Contractor's Role:

  • They are the on-site leaders, managing day-to-day operations.
  • Responsible for hiring and managing subcontractors, such as electricians and plumbers.
  • Ensure compliance with local building codes and standards.

Metaphor

Think of the construction manager as the conductor of an orchestra, ensuring every instrument plays in harmony, while the general contractor is the first chair violinist, essential to the performance but focused on their specific task.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Timing

Step #2: Timing Matters

• Construction Managers are involved from the beginning, during the design phase. They help plan the project, set timelines, and manage pre-construction tasks.
• General Contractors typically come onboard during the construction phase. However, involving them early can help with budgeting and scheduling.

Timing Case Study

In a recent office building project, a construction manager was hired early on to coordinate with engineers and designers. Later, a general contractor was brought in to manage the actual building process. This strategic timing ensured that the project was completed three months ahead of schedule.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Location

Step #3: Where They Operate

• Construction Managers often work off-site, visiting periodically to ensure everything is on track.
• General Contractors are on-site daily, overseeing the construction crew and managing the build.

Location Insight

A construction manager’s off-site presence allows them to focus on big-picture elements like managing budgets and timelines, while the general contractor's on-site presence ensures day-to-day tasks are executed effectively.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Cost

Step #4: Budgeting and Costs

• Construction Manager Costs: Typically range from 5% to 15% of the total project cost.
• General Contractor Costs: Usually 10% to 20% of the project cost, or a daily rate between $300 and $500.

Cost Example

In a residential renovation project, hiring a construction manager could save money in the long run by preventing costly mistakes during planning, while a general contractor ensures that materials are procured at the best rates and used effectively.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Financial Risk

Step #5: Who Bears the Risk?

• Construction Managers have less financial risk as they oversee rather than execute the project.
• General Contractors bear more risk, as they are responsible for the construction and any issues that arise on-site.

Risk Story

A general contractor once faced a budget overrun due to unforeseen structural issues. However, because the construction manager had built contingencies into the budget, the financial impact was minimized.

Construction Managers vs. General Contractors: Qualifications

Step #6: Required Qualifications

• Construction Managers: Often hold degrees in construction management or engineering. While licensing might not be mandatory, experience is critical.
• General Contractors: Must be licensed and bonded, ensuring they meet industry standards and provide financial protection.

Qualification Insight

When hiring, consider a construction manager's experience and a general contractor’s licensing to ensure your project is in capable hands.

Tips and Reminders

1. Evaluate Project Size: For larger projects, consider hiring both a construction manager and a general contractor.
2. Check References: Always ask for references and past project examples.
3. Understand Contracts: Ensure clear terms are laid out in contracts to avoid misunderstandings.

Conclusion

Choosing the right professional for your construction project can determine its success. Whether you opt for a construction manager, a general contractor, or both, understanding their roles and responsibilities will help you make an informed decision.

Ready to stop guessing and start estimating like a pro? Try Estimero free today at Estimero.com — your smarter way to estimate any project.

FAQs

1. Is a construction manager necessary for all projects?

   • Not always. For smaller projects, a general contractor might suffice.

2. Can a general contractor also act as a construction manager?

   • Yes, some contractors offer both services, but ensure they have the necessary qualifications and experience.

3. How do I decide between hiring a construction manager or a general contractor?

   • Consider the project's complexity, your budget, and your experience in managing construction projects.

4. What questions should I ask potential hires?

   • Ask about their experience, past projects, approach to budgeting, and how they handle unexpected issues.

5. How do I ensure my project stays on budget?

   • Regularly consult with your construction manager or contractor, review financial reports, and address issues promptly.

By understanding the unique roles of construction managers and general contractors, you can ensure your project runs smoothly from start to finish.