How to Estimate and Replace a Broken Window Yourself

Introduction

So... your window’s cracked, shattered, or just plain busted.

Whether a stray baseball, storm damage, or old age did it—you're probably asking

“Can I replace this myself, and how much will it cost?”

Short answer: Yes, many single or double-hung windows can be replaced DIY—especially if the frame is still intact. And with rising service costs in 2025, doing it yourself can save $200–$600 or more in labor.

This guide covers:

• How to assess the damage and size the job

• A realistic 2025 cost breakdown

• Tools and materials needed

• Step-by-step replacement process

• When to call a pro (and when not to)

Let’s fix that view—without smashing your budget.

---

🧮 Step 1: Estimate Your Replacement Window Cost

There are two main components:

• The window itself

• Tools & materials for install

Here’s what to expect in 2025 DIY pricing:

| Window Type | Material Cost (2025) | Installed by Pro | DIY Savings |

|------------------------|----------------------|------------------|-------------|

| Single-hung vinyl | $120–$250 | $350–$600 | ~$200+

| Double-hung vinyl | $200–$400 | $450–$750 | ~$250+

| Sliding window | $250–$500 | $500–$800 | ~$300+

| Fixed pane (picture) | $100–$300 | $300–$600 | ~$200+

| Casement/awning | $300–$600 | $600–$900 | ~$300+

🧠 Tip: Use Estimero’s “DIY Window Repair” calculator to estimate total project cost, tools, and time by window type and size.

---

📏 Measure Your Window Opening

You’ll need 3 measurements

1. Width: Inside frame, top/middle/bottom

2. Height: Inside frame, left/middle/right

3. Depth: Between inside & outside stops

Use the smallest width & height numbers when ordering the replacement.

📌 Most big-box stores stock common sizes, but for odd dimensions, expect 2–4 week custom orders.

---

🛠️ Tools and Supplies You'll Need

Required Tools

• Pry bar

• Utility knife

• Hammer

• Caulking gun

• Tape measure

• Screwdriver or drill

• Level

Optional (but helpful)

• Oscillating tool (for trim or sill removal)

• Putty knife

• Shims

Materials

• Window unit (vinyl or composite is easiest DIY)

• Window/door caulk (exterior-grade)

• Foam insulation

• Finish nails or screws

• Trim (if replacing)

• Flashing tape (if needed)

💡 Estimero will auto-generate a material checklist based on your window type and size.

---

🔧 Step 3: Remove the Old Window (Safely)

1. Remove stops and trim carefully (save them for re-use if not replacing)

2. Cut any paint or caulk lines with utility knife

3. Pry loose the window sash or unit

4. Check the frame for damage—rot = pro time

5. Clean the opening before install

⚠️ Be gentle. Old frames can crack if you go full Hulk-mode.

---

🪟 Step 4: Install the New Window

1. Dry fit the window into the opening

2. Apply caulk to the sill and around stops

3. Insert window, center it, and check level

4. Use shims to adjust and keep square

5. Screw it in, per manufacturer specs

6. Insulate gaps with low-expansion foam

7. Replace or install trim

8. Caulk around edges for weatherproofing

9. Test open/close before calling it done

🎯 Install time for a beginner: 2–4 hours for one window

---

💸 What You’ll Likely Spend (All-In DIY)

| Line Item | Estimated Cost |

|------------------------|----------------|

| Vinyl window (32"x54") | $200

| Caulk & foam sealant | $20

| Tools (if new) | $75–$150

| Trim (optional) | $30–$100

| Total DIY Cost | $250–$450

| Cost with Pro Labor | $500–$800+

---

🧠 When to DIY vs. Call a Pro

Go DIY if

• Frame is still solid

• You're replacing a standard-size unit

• You’re handy with basic tools

• It’s a ground-floor window (safer)

Hire a pro if

• Window is cracked in a multi-pane sealed unit

• There’s structural damage, rot, or moisture inside wall

• Window is on a second story

• It’s a large bay or bow window

📌 Estimero lets you compare DIY vs. Pro versions side-by-side to make the smart call.

---

FAQs: Window Replacement Cost & DIY Tips

Q: Is it cheaper to repair glass only? A: Maybe—but most sealed double-pane windows can’t be resealed. If foggy or cracked, a full sash or unit swap is usually smarter.

Q: Can I just replace the insert, not the whole frame? A: Yes—called a “pocket replacement.” As long as your existing frame is square and rot-free, it’s the easiest DIY method.

Q: How long will it last if I DIY it? A: With proper sealing and install, a vinyl replacement window should last 15–25 years—even as a DIY job.

---

Final Thoughts: Clear Costs, Clear Views

Fixing a broken window doesn’t have to be intimidating—or expensive. With the right prep and a simple checklist, you can replace most standard windows yourself and save hundreds.

Here’s your action plan:

1. Measure accurately

2. Use Estimero to estimate total costs

3. Shop smart (watch for bundle deals)

4. Take your time installing

5. Insulate and seal like a pro

💡 Ready to price your window replacement? Use Estimero to get a precise cost estimate, build your materials list, and choose between DIY and pro with confidence.

---

Helpful Links - Estimero DIY Window Estimator

• Top 10 DIY Projects That Improve Home Value

• DIY vs. Contractor Cost Breakdown

---

Need help planning your first window replacement? Reach out to Estimero Support and we’ll guide you from estimate to install—step by step.